← Back to the journal

How to Listen Before Giving Advice

Watercolor illustration of two friends talking over tea at a sunlit kitchen table

A friend sits down at your kitchen table and says, “I had the worst day.” Before they’ve set their cup down, you already have an idea about what they should do. You want to make things easier for them. There’s something worth doing before you offer that idea. Give them a chance to tell you what made the day so hard.

Maybe it was the extra work. Maybe it was the way a colleague spoke to them in front of everyone. If you guess too soon, you might give perfectly sensible advice about the wrong part of the story.

Let the story get past the first sentence

Put down what you’re holding if you can. Give the person a moment to finish, even if they pause in the middle. Then ask a question you’re genuinely curious about. “Which part of the day is still with you?” leaves room for an answer you couldn’t have predicted. The CDC’s guide to supportive conversations includes similar suggestions about setting distractions aside and asking open-ended questions.

One question is often enough. There’s no need to fill every silence. If your friend keeps talking, follow the part of the story they choose to tell next.

Say what you heard, and let them correct you

Try putting one detail into your own words. “It sounds like it hurt that nobody backed you up.” Then leave a little room. Your friend might say, “Actually, I think I was more embarrassed than hurt.” That correction gives you a better sense of what the day felt like from their side.

The University of Maine Cooperative Extension’s active listening guide describes ways to restate what someone said and check whether you understood it. You can keep the wording as simple as you would in any other conversation. If you get it wrong, try “Thanks for telling me. I heard that differently at first.”

Ask before you offer a next step

When you’re tempted to say, “Here’s what you should do,” try a question first. “Would you like to think through what to say tomorrow, or would it help to talk a little longer?” Either answer gives you something useful to do. If they ask for ideas, share one and see how it lands. If they want to keep talking, let the tea get a little cooler.

You can practice this in an ordinary conversation today. Wait for the other person to finish, check one thing you think you understood, and give them the choice of whether to hear your idea. You may still end up offering the very same advice. By then, you’ll know a little more about the person who’ll have to decide what to do with it.

Further reading

Leave a Reply